Advanced Combustion Systems - Systems Analysis

Systems analysis in support of the Advanced Combustion Systems Program consists of conducting various energy analyses that provide input to decisions on issues such as national plans and programs, resource use, environmental and energy security policies, technology options for research and development programs, and paths to deployment of energy technology.

The system analysis work includes technology, benefits, and current situation and trends analyses related to advanced CO2 emissions control. Systems analyses and economic modeling of new technologies are crucial to providing sound guidance to R&D efforts. In these analyses, a conceptual design is first generated with emphasis on mass and energy balances. Based on available data and/or engineering estimates, these systems are optimized, and "what-if" scenarios are evaluated to identify barriers to deployment and help the technology developers establish system performance targets.

Reports that have been generated describing systems analyses in support of advanced combustion R&D efforts are shown in the tables below.

Cost and Performance Baselines for Fossil Energy Power Plants

Volume 1a - Bituminous Coal (PC) and Natural Gas to Electricity


Establishes performance and cost data for fossil energy power systems, pulverized coal (PC) plants fueled with bituminous coal and natural gas combined cycle (NGCC) plants, all with and without carbon capture and storage. The analyses were performed on a consistent technical and economic basis that reflects current market conditions. The study serves as a benchmark to track the progress of DOE Fossil Energy R&D and as a baseline for analyzing fossil energy plant options. This is believed to provide the most comprehensive set of cost and performance data using bituminous coal available in the public literature to date. The cost and performance data were compiled from published reports, information obtained from vendor quotes and users of the technology, and data from designing and building utility projects.
July 2015 DOE/NETL-2015/1723

Advanced Combustion Systems – Systems Analysis Studies 

Performance Baseline for Oxy-Coal MHD Power Plant with Carbon Capture This presentation discusses the development of baseline Direct Power Extraction (DPE) plant designs incorporating oxy-coal combustion, a magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) topping cycle, a steam bottoming cycle, and a carbon dioxide purification unit for carbon capture and storage (CCS). Two MHD configurations have been developed; one representing the current state-of-the-art in MHD channel design, and a more advanced design capable of higher power density. The modeled performance of the two DPE plant systems are compared to IGCC and oxy-coal AUSC reference plants with CCS.
  May 2016 NETL-PUB-20286

Guidance for NETL’s Oxy-combustion R&D Program: Chemical Looping Combustion Reference Plant Designs and Sensitivity Studies

An emerging, coal-fired power plant technology, chemical looping combustion (CLC), is assessed in this report.  CLC technology is, in essence, an oxy-combustion technology being developed with focus on its potential for improved performance and reduced cost. Its benefits are measured against performance and cost of the conventional pulverized coal (PC) power plant using amine-based CO2 absorption for post-combustion carbon capture.  This study develops National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL) reference CLC plant configurations and assumptions that are used to evaluate CLC system performance and cost.
December 2014 DOE/NETL-2014/1643

Impact of Load Following on Power Plant Cost and Performance

This study performed a review of the public literature and interviewed industry experts to determine the impact on cost and performance of forcing fossil fuel power plants without and with carbon capture to load follow in response to changes in demand or output from renewable power generation sources. There is some information to quantify the impact of load following on NGCC and PC plants without capture, however there is little information either experimental data or theoretical analysis on the impact on IGCC, oxy-combustion, or any plants with carbon capture from load following.
October 2012 DOE/NETL-2013/1592

Advancing Oxy-combustion Technology for Bituminous Coal Power Plants: An R&D Guide

The National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL) is funding research aimed at improving the performance and reducing the cost of oxy-combustion. The objective of this study is to guide oxy-combustion research in areas that can provide the largest benefits in electricity cost and plant performance. The advanced oxy-combustion technologies evaluated in this study are categorized into four major areas: advanced boiler design, advanced oxygen production, advanced flue gas treatment, and innovative CO2 compression concepts.
April 2012 NETL/DOE-2010/1405

Fossil Energy RD&D: Reducing the Cost of CCUS for Coal Power Plants

DOE’s Office of Fossil Energy, NETL implements research, development and demonstration (RD&D) programs that are moving aggressively to address the challenge of reducing greenhouse gas emissions as a climate change mitigation strategy. In partnership with both the Nation’s research universities and the private sector, RD&D efforts are focused on maximizing system efficiency and performance, while minimizing the costs of new Carbon Capture, Utilization and Storage (CCUS) technologies. Improving the efficiency of power generation systems reduces emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2) as well as other criteria pollutants while using less water and extending the life of our domestic energy resource base.
January 2012 DOE/NETL-2012/1550

Cost Performance for Low-Rank Pulverized Coal Oxy-combustion Energy Plants

This report provides analyses on oxy-combustion of lignite and subbituminous coals in PC and CFBC power plants. Steam conditions examined are supercritical and ultra-supercritical. In addition, various CO2 purification techniques were compared.
September 2010 DOE/NETL-401/093010

DOE NETL's Carbon Capture R&D Program for Existing Coal Fired Power Plants

A review and assessment of the DOE research and development (R&D) program directed specifically at post- and oxy-combustion CO2 capture technologies that can be retrofit to existing coal-fired power plants, and designed into new plants. The strategic plan for this program includes the development of advanced CO2 capture and compression technologies for both existing and new coal-fired power plants that, when combined, can achieve 90 percent CO2 capture at less than a 35 percent increase in cost of electricity (COE). Such technologies could then be available for commercial use by 2020.
February 2009 DOE/NETL-2009/1356

NETL Carbon Sequestration Program: US Perspective on CO2 Capture and Separation

This presentation outlines the NETL Carbon Sequestration Program and the pre- and post-combustion technologies under which CO2 capture is proposed. The presentation also discusses the modeling and assessment tools used to evaluate the performance of each technology. The final section reviews ongoing R&D projects and highlights their progress.
April 2004