Oil & Natural Gas Projects
Exploration and Production Technologies
Implementing a Novel Cyclic CO2 Flood in Paleozoic Reefs
This project was in response to DOE's Preferred Upstream Management Practices
(PUMP III) solicitation, DE-PS26-02NT15378. The goals of the PUMP program are
to slow the decline of America's oil production by pairing new technologies
and best practices to an aggressive technology transfer program directed to
The primary goals of this project are to demonstrate that significant quantities
of by-passed hydrocarbons can be recovered from pinnacle reefs using a novel
CO2 cycling technology by conducting a field demonstration; identify abandoned
or shut-in reefs that are suitable candidates for similar recovery efforts;
and communicate the project results and data to small independent producers
via an aggressive technology transfer program.
Michigan Technological University
A production response of more than 80 barrels of oil per day has resulted from
the initial stage of repressurization of a depleted Niagaran pinnacle reef using
Antrim waste CO2 that would otherwise have been vented to the atmosphere. Detailed
reservoir modeling of Niagaran reefs using the technique of well log tomography
is producing a new reservoir characterization tool that can be used for the
visualization of permeability and porosity distribution in oil and gas reservoirs.
The project is a simple operation that can be widely implemented at a relatively
low cost if it can be demonstrated to be economic. It is expected the demonstration
well in Otsego County will produce an additional 400,000 to 600,000 barrels
of oil that is nearly the original production, and at that rate will be economic.
Estimated costs to acquire, compress, inject and recover the oil are about $3
million. The breakeven point would be at about 200,000 barrels assuming $17/barrel
oil. An extensive belt around the northern and southern margins in Michigan
has proven reef production, with over 700 reefs discovered. Assuming that 100
reefs could be candidates for CO2 injection, and assuming an average recovery
of 400,000 barrels, the basin-wide recovery approaches 40 million barrels. For
this project, about 17 reefs and 130 wells have been identified in the vicinity
of the proposed demonstration well. This region will be evaluated for enhanced
recovery potential as part of this project.
Since the CO2 to be injected will come from nearby Antrim production, an additional
benefit will be to sequester this CO2 rather than venting it to the atmosphere.
In addition to the write-up of the field trial, the Basin reef inventory will
be in a digital format with pertinent engineering and geological characteristics.
The economics of the process in terms of secondary recovery of hydrocarbons
will be evaluated.
The intracratonic basins of North America (the Michigan, Williston, Illinois
and Appalachian Basins) contain large numbers of pinnacle reefs (Catacosinos
et. al., 1991; Fisher et. al., 1988). In the Michigan Basin, the total number
of reef fields discovered exceeds 700, with over 300 million barrels of oil
and 2 trillion cubic feet of gas produced. Most of these wells are now shut-in
or plugged and abandoned, even though the primary recoveries were only 25 -
40% and they are known to contain large quantities of by-passed oil. Clearly
these reefs are valuable resources and obvious targets for enhanced recovery.
To date they have not been subjected to many enhanced recovery attempts even
though many of them are thought capable of producing a volume of hydrocarbons
nearly equal to the original primary recovery, in some cases an additional 250,000
- 500,000 barrels of oil per reef.
Two attempts have been made to produce the Michigan pinnacle reefs by CO2 injection
and they appear to have been reasonable successful. Reported additional production
due to CO2 injection is 160,000 and 430,000 barrels, respectively. Those volumes
represent 14% and 33% of the primary recovery in just 5 years. One of these
attempts, at Dover Field in Otsego County, is close to the proposed demonstration
well and judging from production data released to the State of Michigan, the
CO2 nearly restored the production to initial conditions. However, aside from
state-mandated disclosures, the details of the operations have not been made
public and this has been a serious impediment to widespread adoption of this
Pinnacle reefs have a high vertical relief and are also nearly hermetically
sealed. CO2 will be injected into the top of the reef and the hydrocarbons will
be collected from a horizontal drain well drilled at the base of the reef.
The CO2 will be obtained from nearby gas wells producing from the Antrim Formation
where the gas will be compressed and dehydrated, then piped a short distance
(1 mile) to the demonstration well. There it will be injected to bring the reef
back to nearly virgin pressure and the re-mobilized hydrocarbons will tend to
migrate to the bottom of the reservoir as the gas cap expands. This CO2 is currently
vented to atmosphere as a waste product.
Nearby well logs that penetrate the reef will be analyzed using a new approach
that has been developed at Michigan Technological University. This approach
has been termed Log Curve Amplitude Slicing (LCAS) and uses suites of well logs
to map the horizon of interest at 1-foot intervals, essentially utilizing the
full information content of the log. The technique is similar to mapping formation
tops from log picks or drillers reports except that the attribute is mapped
at much more closely spaced intervals (e.g. 1 foot).
In this project, the horizontal resolution is expected to be as good as or
better than 3D seismic. LCAS has been used to map the Traverse Formation in
the central Michigan Basin using the gamma log. A previous study showed that
the gamma ray could be used to map depositional units (low gamma = clean limestone,
high gamma = shale, etc.) in a very plausible manner. This study showed that
deltas encroached and withdrew from the basin at various times corresponding
to events in the hinterlands. There have been several reefs located with multiple
wells, up to 20, that can be used in a similar fashion to map reef facies. The
wells have multiple logs so a number of attributes can be mapped.
This project will focus on mapping lithology/deposition environment and porosity.
If this technique is successful it will provide a useful tool for analyzing
reefs and planning production strategies. The methodology has been worked out
and applied on a basin scale and this project will use the same technique on
a smaller (field) scale with a higher log, or sample, density. A key component
to any successful secondary or enhanced recovery operation is detailed reservoir
characterization. This project will acquire all available geologic and engineering
data for the study area. Cores and core analyses are available for several wells
in the study area. Reservoir pressure data was regularly collected throughout
the primary phase of production. Monthly and annual production history data
is also available. These data along with the wire line log data derived from
the LCAS process, will be integrated to build an interactive database and geologic
Current Status (December 2004)
The demonstration project is in year two of operation. Injection of CO2 began
in May 2004 into one recompleted well. In July 2004 a second well was recompleted
as an injector. Initial production response has been extraordinary - 9 barrels
of oil per day (bopd) to 90 bopd. Our industry partners are optimistic that
the producing well may actually transition from pumping to flowing as reservoir
pressure increases from CO2 injection. Antrim waste CO2 was used in initial
repressurization but economic and logistical considerations has resulted in
the use of recycled Antrim CO2 from the nearby Dover 33- and 36-industry projects.
Future project performance will determine the viability of placing a horizontal
well bore at the base of the reef. One or more additional CO2 floods are being
permitted in the vicinity of the demonstration project in other Niagaran pinnacle
Visualization of a Belle River Mills reef showing core permeability voxels.
Visualization of a Belle River Mills reef showing core permeability voxels >25md
(green) and >13md (red).
Wylie, A. S., Jr. and Wood, J. R., in press, 3D-Imaging of Core and Log Curve
Amplitudes in a Niagaran Reef, Belle River Mills Field, St. Clair County, Michigan,
U.S.: AAPG Bulletin, expected publication April 2005.
Budget period annual and semi-annual reports are available at http://www.geo.mtu.edu/svl/PumpIII/index.html
or from NETL.
Project Start: September 25, 2002
Project End: December 31, 2005
Anticipated DOE Contribution: $1.1 million
Performer Contribution: $1.1 million (50% of total)
NETL - Dan Gurney (firstname.lastname@example.org or 918-699-2063)
Michigan Tech U. - James Wood (email@example.com or 906-487-2894)